It’s Monday! What Are You Reading? #imwayr 11/10/14


Visit Unleashing Readers and Teach Mentor Texts to participate in the kidlit version of this weekly meme.

On my blog:

  • A collection of links to this week’s best online reading about teaching, reading, and writing
  • A celebration of doodling, team sketchbooks, creativity challenges, and healing
  • A reflection on my year, so far, in reading nonfiction for Nonfiction November
  • A review of Dream Something Big, a nonfiction picture book about the building of the Watts Towers
  • A Top Ten List of Books I Want to Reread

In reading:

Part of my November creativity challenge is to read something each day about creativity. This week I finished two books that relate:

david lynch

David Lynch’s Catching the Big Fish: Meditation, Consciousness, and Creativity is probably best suited for serious Lynch fans or filmmakers, as many of the very brief chapters focus quite specifically on his films, sometimes too technically for the casual movie fan to follow. The book starts off strong: Lynch practices transcendental meditation and believes that this practice helps him gain access to his unconscious mind, where he fishes for the big ideas in his artistic work. The beginning of the book suggests that Lynch will share how this process has worked for him and how he uses meditation to create. But after the first few chapters, there is very little about meditation and not very much about big ideas. Lynch reminisces about this and that, often in a free association kind of way, and barely touches on a topic before moving on to the next. Overall, not a lot of substance here.

picture thisLynda Barry created Picture This to explore a single question: why do we stop drawing? If you want answers or need lots of words to help you think about that question, this isn’t the book for you. It’s more suggestive and evocative than anything else. There are comics and cartoons plus some interesting written reflections on Barry’s own artistic process. But the bulk of the book is weird drawings and doodles plus lots and lots of full-page cartoons of one of Barry’s alter-egos, the nearsighted monkey. This is definitely not a book for everyone, and I do understand readers who were disappointed, thinking they were getting one thing (“Do you wish you could draw?,” the cover asks,”Take Art Lessons from a Monkey”) when really they were getting something else. This isn’t a book about how to draw, though it will encourage you to doodle and use drawing as a kind of active meditation. I like the way Barry is always able to get me thinking–and quite often that thinking comes from image and the juxtaposition of images, not from words. It’s a very different way for me to use my brain.

days of blood and starlight

This week, I finished Days of Blood and Starlight, the second book in Laini Taylor’s magnificent trilogy. I was planning to wait until next year to read Book 3 because I have so many unfinished reading challenges from 2014 that I need to wrap up in the next 6 weeks. But I can’t wait. The story is just too compelling. I’ve listened to the whole series on audio, brilliantly narrated by Kristine Hvam.

misadventures of family fletcher

I enjoyed Dana Alison Levy’s middle-grade novel, The Misadventures of the Family Fletcher. If you like the Melendy family, the Penderwicks, or the Casson family, you’ll probably like the Family Fletcher. There are two dads and four boys adopted from a variety of backgrounds, and the episodic story follows the family through a school year of adventures and misadventures. There’s not a lot in the way of plot, but plot really isn’t the point. The story works because of its characters, who are interesting, engaging, and believable.

bits and pieces

I strongly dislike the Skippyjon Jones books (I know, I know), but I adored Judy Schachner’s Bits & Pieces. It is not a perfect picture book: it feels as if Schachner hasn’t sufficiently fictionalized this story of her somewhat dim-witted real-life cat, Tink. The pacing is off at certain points as Schachner tries to squeeze 20 years of her cat’s life into one 32-page picture book, and in an effort to cover a lot of ground at the end of the story, the amount of text per page dramatically changes (single sentences at the beginning of the book; giant paragraphs at the end). But though I can objectively recognize that this book needed a little more work, it was still the perfect picture book for me. There are moments of absolute cat perfection early in the story. If you love cats–and especially if you’ve known a dim cat or two and loved them anyway–then this is the book for you.

rex wrecks it

Ben Clanton’s Rex Wrecks It! is so good. Poor energetic Rex gets excluded from other kids’ fun because he has an unfortunate habit of wrecking everything. The story of how they all learn to play together, despite Rex’s propensity for destruction, is quite satisfying.

waiting is not easy

The new Elephant & Piggie is, of course, wonderful. I know I always say this when I review a new Mo Willems, but seriously, how does he keep making one classic picture book after another? Piggie has a surprise for Gerald, but he’s going to have to wait, and, well, it’s not easy.

shh we have a plan

Chris Haughton’s Shh! We Have a Plan is gorgeously colored–those saturated blues and purples and then the eye-popping reds, oranges, and pinks of the flock of birds–and quite funny as the three who have the plan bumble their way through the story, trying and repeatedly failing to catch the bird, never learning from the littlest one who could show them the right way. Very simple spare text and repetition makes it suitable for the very youngest readers, but it also has strong older kid and adult appeal. extraordinary jane

Extraordinary Jane is a lovely story of a very ordinary dog who doesn’t seem to have any particular talents. Jane and her family work for a circus, and all of the other dogs have very special gifts. Jane tries to figure out what’s special about her. It turns out that simply being a very good dog is special enough. Hannah Harrison’s artwork is extraordinary–there is so much to enjoy visually in this book.





14 responses to “It’s Monday! What Are You Reading? #imwayr 11/10/14”

  1. Michele Knott Avatar

    Lots of good picture books this week, Elisabeth! I so agree with you about Mo Willems – the man is a machine! I’ve seen a few positive reviews of the Family Fletcher book. It sounds interesting, I may have to pick it up at some point!

    1. Elisabeth Ellington Avatar

      I treated myself to a bookstore visit this week–love getting a chance to look at some PBs my libraries don’t have yet! I always feel a little guilty for using the bookstore as a library but I also always buy something!

  2. Linda Baie Avatar

    Oh Carrie, how can I put still another good YA book onto my list (Smoke & Bone)! There are so many good ones to read. Must get that Elephant & Piggie-so cute & funny & satisfying. I have Picture This, & it’s a great one to share with the older students. They adore looking at it & getting inspired. And I loved The Family Fletcher; hope it gets some good middle grade love this year. Thanks for all!

    1. Linda Baie Avatar

      Oh my goodness, I’ve done it again, Elisabeth. I thought I’d clicked on Carrie’s blog. Yikes, I’m moving too quickly. Thanks for understanding. I loved hearing about your books like always. Feel free to delete!!

      1. carriegelson Avatar

        I don’t mind being confused with Elisabeth! She has excellent taste!

    2. Elisabeth Ellington Avatar

      LOL, Linda, I don’t mind at all! I know just what you mean about moving too quickly. I’ll sometimes about 15 tabs open as I’m commenting on Monday posts! Easy to lose our place. Love hearing that the older students enjoy Picture This and find inspiration there. I don’t read a lot of YA series (or rather, I read a lot of first books in series and never go on to finish!), but the Daughter of Smoke & Bone series really is phenomenal. Laini Taylor can WRITE!

  3. Ricki Ginsberg Avatar
    Ricki Ginsberg

    Picture This looks fantastic. I want to find a copy of it. I’ll admit that when I read your reviews, I get a bit lost in your beautiful descriptions. You are such a phenomenal writer. 🙂

    1. Elisabeth Ellington Avatar

      Thanks so much, Ricki! That means a lot to me. I am slowly working my way this week through Barry’s earlier book, What It Is, which is about writing (though also a lot about drawing and image).

  4. Cheriee Weichel Avatar

    I loved the Misadventures of the Family Fletcher. You are right that it is less about plot than the characters. My how I love that family! Mo Willems is beyond brilliant. If only I could write like that! Shh we have a plan sounds like an amazing book too. I love those picture books that my grade sevens check out ‘to read to their younger siblings.’

    1. Elisabeth Ellington Avatar

      I couldn’t help falling in love with the Fletchers too. I’m an only child and always find it fascinating to read about big families and interesting sibling dynamics! Have you read Hilary McKay’s Casson family series? That’s my absolute favorite of this type of book. I really am in awe of Mo Willems–so few words and such an incredibly strong effect.

  5. Beth Shaum (@BethShaum) Avatar

    Yay! So glad you loved Rex Wrecks It! I feel very satisfied with myself that I found that title by chance at my library because I ended up loving it so much! 🙂

    Extraordinary Jane was such an emotional title for me. I actually wept at the end. The message of “you are enough” is just so powerful, it’s hard not to get emotional.

    1. Elisabeth Ellington Avatar

      I never would have picked up either of those books if I hadn’t read your reviews–I’ve been looking for both of them! And yes, that message of “you are enough” is incredibly powerful and necessary and not one that I think we give enough to children. I found Extraordinary Jane to be quite moving!

  6. carriegelson Avatar

    I must read Family Fletcher. Loved Extraordinary Jane and Shh! We have a plan is so visually wonderful. Really liked it a lot.

    1. Elisabeth Ellington Avatar

      I was surprised at how much I loved Shh! We Have a Plan visually. Those saturated colors! I was thinking I kind of want to buy two copies–one to keep and read, and the other to cut up and frame!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: