Nonfiction Picture Book Wednesday: ALA Media Awards Anticipation Plus Suggestions for Caldecott #nfpb2015

nonfiction picture book challenge 2015


On Monday, February 2, the ALA Youth Media Awards will be announced. I’ll be watching the live webcast and chatting with my nerdy friends on Twitter as the announcements are made. I’m interested in all of the awards, for different reasons.

The Printz is important to my work in Adolescent Literature. When I look through the recent Printz medal and honor books, I find very few books that I really love, though many that I admire. Even though I rarely love a book that wins the Printz, I do adore the committees that select the Printz. Surely no committee works harder to find books that no one has ever heard of to honor. They leave no stone unturned! The Printz is often so far out there that I never bother even speculating about what might win or having favorites. There are sometimes even books on the list that I’ve never read so much as a single review of (hello, White Bicycle!), which is surprising given how much my nerdy PLN reads and reviews.

The Newbery is usually much less of a surprise, and sometimes I’ve even read the medal winner, as I read widely in the middle-grade fiction that Newbery so loves. It’s strangely delightful to have already read the book that wins. I don’t quite understand that particular pleasure, but it is a pleasure.

And then there is the Caldecott. Along with the Sibert, it is the only award where I will most likely have already read the winner and all of the Honor books. (Or they will already be sitting on my shelf, ready to be read.) It is also the only award that I have very strong opinions about every year.

The Caldecott has a much better track record when it comes to honoring nonfiction than either the Printz or the Newbery. Most Caldecott committees honor one nonfiction book even if nonfiction rarely wins gold. Out of 71 winners and honor books since 2000, the Printz has only managed to honor 4 nonfiction books, 5 if you count Heart to Heart: New Poems Inspired by Twentieth-Century American Art. Nonfiction doesn’t fare much better with Newbery, which is especially disappointing given how much very fine nonfiction is published for the under-14 set.

I wonder why the major awards tend to discount nonfiction. I wonder if we assume that nonfiction cannot provide the kind of absorbing reading experience that we know fiction provides or if we believe that literary fiction is more prestigious. Do we overlook the ways that nonfiction must also incorporate the qualities discussed in the awards criteria? With the Caldecott, in particular, do we focus too much on the information in an informational book at the expense of noticing what the art is doing?

Genre diversity isn’t the only kind of diversity I’ll be thinking about on Monday. The Printz, Newbery, and Caldecott all have a dismal track record when it comes to honoring books by authors and illustrators of color. It’s so bad, in fact, that I often wonder why that’s not the only thing people notice about these awards.

When we talk about how #weneeddiversebooks, we also need to talk about how we need librarians to “bless” diverse books with major awards. We need the almost all-white committees that select the winners of the Printz, Newbery, and Caldecott medals to reflect more deeply about white privilege, reading preferences, and prejudices. It’s all well and good to say that these awards aren’t about race, that readers are colorblind when they read. But considering ourselves colorblind while enjoying all the privileges of being white–being able to find thousands of books every year written by people who look like us and featuring characters who look like us, for example–is the very definition of white privilege. And if these awards were truly color-blind, could the lists of awards winners really be so blindingly white year after year after year?

Talking about the whiteness of the major ALA awards makes people uncomfortable–but that doesn’t mean we shouldn’t be talking about it.

Here are five picture books that I hope to see honored on Monday:

josephineright worddrawviva frida

all different now



17 responses to “Nonfiction Picture Book Wednesday: ALA Media Awards Anticipation Plus Suggestions for Caldecott #nfpb2015”

  1. Tara Smith Avatar

    I loved each of these books, too. My daughter was in Mexico City for the holidays and had a chance to visit Frida’s house and museum – I learned so much more about this remarkable artist, and respect her all the more. Aren’t we lucky to be living and teaching in a time so rich with picture book delights?!

    1. Elisabeth Ellington Avatar

      I would LOVE to visit Frida’s house and museum someday. I’ve been lucky enough to see couple of Kahlo exhibits at museums–I love how small and exquisite the paintings are in person. Yes, we are incredibly lucky readers to live in such a golden age of picture books!

  2. Amy @ Sunlit Pages Avatar

    Last year was the first year where I’d read both the Newbery winner and one of the honors, and yes, it gave me a bit of a thrill. 🙂

    I’m unfamiliar with most of your Caldecott choices, and we read a LOT of picture books around here, so I’m kind of ashamed!!!

    1. Elisabeth Ellington Avatar

      I really depend on my nerdy PLN to alert me to wonderful PBs. And then I spend way too much money buying them! Wish my libraries had larger PB collections! I think last year was my best Newbery record–I’d read the winner and 2 honor books. I doubt I’m so lucky this year. I haven’t read as many of the buzzed books.

  3. Linda Baie Avatar

    I’ve read all of your picks except All Different Now, Elisabeth, and agree with you, hope that the awards reflect more diversity this year. We certainly have a good selection from which to choose. Monday will be interesting!

    1. Elisabeth Ellington Avatar

      We certainly do have a good selection of diverse books to choose from, but then I thought we did last year too. SIGH. All Different Now is lovely and important, I think, though I didn’t think it was Lewis’s strongest work. It’s one I need to return to again and reread.

  4. carriegelson Avatar

    Love this post. Great reflections. Important points.

    1. Elisabeth Ellington Avatar

      Thank you! I’m so looking forward to Monday’s announcements!

      1. Scott Day Avatar

        Loved all your selections, especially Viva Frida, Draw, Josephine, and The Right Word. Especially loved Draw and the bird. Would not have read Josephine without your recommendation. A remarkable person.

      2. Elisabeth Ellington Avatar

        So glad you liked Josephine! I’m crazy about Christian Robinson’s art in that one. Draw is amazing–so many great books in 2014, and not all can win awards of course, but I think I was saddest about that one getting overlooked.

  5. Myra GB Avatar

    Sharing your post with my higher-degree students, Elisabeth. Great reflections here. 🙂 Have to find DRAW now. 🙂

  6. Gigi McAllister Avatar

    Excellent post! Love your choices! The Right Word is huge fave!

    1. Elisabeth Ellington Avatar

      The Right Word is, for me, the most distinguished PB of the year. Wish I could get my students more excited about it, though.

  7. jaydenelizabeth13 Avatar

    This makes me miss our Digital Literacy class read aloud sessions! I agree that it is awesome to have already won a book that won an award! I think the pleasure comes from enjoying something before it was popular, it is kind of like knowing a secret before everyone else!

    1. Elisabeth Ellington Avatar

      That must be it, Jayden: it’s like being in on the secret! I miss reading aloud to all of you too! I liked the flexibility and openness of that class so much!

  8. […] give my students that little thrill of being in on the secret, at Jayden puts it in a comment on a post I wrote earlier this week about the ALA […]

  9. […] ALA Youth Media Awards speculation and predictions […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: