It’s Monday! What Are You Reading? #imwayr 10/12/15


Visit Teach Mentor Texts and Unleashing Readers to participate in the kidlit version of this weekly meme.

On the blog:

In reading:

beautiful darkness

I knew nothing about Beautiful Darkness when I checked it out from the library last week. Then I happened to be skimming book blogs that very same afternoon and came across a review of the book that started something like “Well, I’m still traumatized for life by Beautiful Darkness.” I just thought, ugh. I can’t read a book that’s going to traumatize me for life. But there it was, and there I was, and I got just a little bit curious. I mean, there’s a little wide-eyed doll-like creature in some pretty leaves on the cover. How bad could it be? Somehow my eyes managed to avoid processing that thing the wide-eyed doll creature is hiding behind: A DECOMPOSING HAND. This is SO not my kind of book, but once I started reading, I was hooked, and I ended up really loving it and thinking easily of a dozen students I want to recommend it to. I laughed out loud numerous times–not because it’s funny, though it is sometimes very funny in a dark way–but because I was so horrified by the things that were happening and so surprised by the twists and turns of the story. The art is often very disturbing, but also very beautiful. The story is strongly allegorical–about survival, the lengths we go to for it, how quickly our organized and civilized ways can disappear when we’re in survival mode. A must-read, though perhaps not for the squeamish.

leo a ghost story

I always worry when a picture book is as highly anticipated as Leo: A Ghost Story was for me. One of my very favorite writers of PBs paired with one of my very favorite illustrators of PBs? Sometimes such high expectations make a reading fall flat–not through any fault of the book. Leo has been sitting at the top of my stack for a couple of weeks, daring me to read it. I finely got brave this weekend and cracked the cover. Robinson’s palette and artistic choices are always surprising, yet also always distinctly his work, and the story is charming, humorous and full of heart. A winner.

My favorite Christian Robinson title this week, though, was Rain!, written by Linda Ashman. I’m crazy about the art and crazy about the story, which contrasts the reactions of a child and an old man to a rainy day. Such a wise meditation upon perspective. Also, the old man’s grouchiness is eventually cured in part by a cookie, and this is a life philosophy I can get behind.

the day i lost my superpowers

The Day I Lost My Superpowers relies on the juxtaposition of text and image for much of its humor, as the images tell a slightly different story from the text. Discovering a flying superpower, for instance, simply means jumping off the bed. My son is off picture books right now, but if he were open to listening to them, this is one I would want to share, both for the lovely line and image about going back in time (where the child pretends to be a baby again and is held by her mother) and for the conclusion, where our superhero hurts herself but the pain disappears after a bit of soothing from her mother.

city cat

I loved Lauren Castillo’s illustrations in City Cat, but I couldn’t suspend disbelief enough to enjoy the story. It’s about a stray cat who stows away and joins a family on their European vacation. Part of the fun of the illustrations is identifying all the famous monuments of Europe and spotting the cat hanging out in each picture. But I was too worried about the cat’s health and safety. These are big busy cities! All kinds of bad things could happen! Even though I knew the cat wasn’t going to get run over by a car or attacked by a dog, I still couldn’t relax.

David Ezra Stein’s Leaves is pretty much picture book perfection. It doesn’t break any new ground: a young bear experiences the four seasons for the first time, and he’s confused in fall, cozy in winter, and delighted by spring, just as you would expect. But it’s perfectly done. I love Stein’s exuberant loose lines, and the simple text is surprisingly poetic.





21 responses to “It’s Monday! What Are You Reading? #imwayr 10/12/15”

  1. Laura Cooper Avatar

    Ok–now I have to go check out Beautiful Darkness!! Sounds creepy. And Leo is next up on my pile. Looking forward to it.

    1. Elisabeth Ellington Avatar

      Leo is a delight. And Beautiful Darkness is definitely creepy and disturbing. The art is also amazing!

  2. runawaylibrarian Avatar

    I’m dead curious about Beautiful Darkness. What age range would you think? SLJ says gr. 9 and up, but I’m wondering if it could go slightly younger.

    1. Elisabeth Ellington Avatar

      Hmmm…. 9 and up seems about right to me, though I know some 7th and 8th graders who would really like it. (I also know some 7th graders who would be scarred for life!) There are several very disturbing images.

  3. Lisa Maucione (@DrLMaucione) Avatar

    Beautiful Darkness sounds intriquing. The cover is just so odd. Sounds like some important themes within the book which would make for some interesting discussions with older readers.

    1. Elisabeth Ellington Avatar

      It’s definitely a book I’d like to discuss with other readers. It would make an interesting pairing with Lord of the Flies.

  4. Tara Smith Avatar

    You have my curiosity piqued with Beautiful Darkness…but I will read it on a bright, sunny day.

    1. Elisabeth Ellington Avatar

      That sounds like the right kind of day for it!

  5. Ricki Ginsberg Avatar

    The Day I Lost my Superpowers seems like a clever text. I wish I was an idea person, so I could think of these things! Have a great reading week!

    1. Elisabeth Ellington Avatar

      I know! Such a simple idea, so clever, so seemingly obvious once you read it!

  6. Beth Shaum (@BethShaum) Avatar

    I had not heard of Rain before. I must seek that one out!

  7. carriegelson Avatar

    I really liked The Day I Lost my Superpowers. Lots of great titles this week!

    1. Elisabeth Ellington Avatar

      I didn’t finish a lot, but what I did finish was very good!

  8. Michele Avatar

    That first one does sound creepy! I do love Lauren Castillo’s artwork. I love Nana and Troublemaker most of all. Yard Sale was a winner as was The Reader. I hope one day she does something about a hedgehog!
    You did have a Christian Robinson week!

    1. Elisabeth Ellington Avatar

      I love Lauren Castillo’s artwork too. I don’t think I’ve read The Reader–off to search for that one. Troublemaker is possibly my favorite.

  9. Jane Whittingham Avatar

    Beautiful Darkness….I don’t know, now I think I have to at least skim through it! I love Leo – I’ve been sharing it with school groups as an unexpected Halloween book – something seasonally appropriate, but also a bit different. Excellent choices!!

  10. jayciecheatham Avatar

    Oh my goodness, City Cat sounds really intense! Isn’t that funny? We are more on the edge of our seats for a children’s book about a stray cat than we are while reading a Gillian Flynn novel… I don’t even know if I can put this one on my “Want to Read” list – do you think I can handle it?

  11. cheriee Avatar

    I will not be reading Beautiful Darkness (I couldn’t finish Doll Bones after all) However, I do have Leo: A Ghost Story ready to pick up at kidsbooks, and will have to pick up The Day I Lost My Superpowers when I am there. These Mondays are so expensive!

  12. Myra GB Avatar

    I just shared my thoughts about Beautiful Darkness last week for Monday reading. Very Lord of the Flies with pygmies and supernatural creatures thrown into the mix. While I usually go for the really strange stories, somehow this one failed to hit the mark for me. I still liked it though. Loved the illustrations most of all.

  13. reedjudd Avatar

    You have a great selection of books for this week’s post! Reading all the comments, I especially want to check out “Leo, A Ghost Story.” Also, “Beautiful Darkness” looks interesting too! My future books reading list is growing larger and larger.

Leave a Reply to Elisabeth Ellington Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: