It’s Monday! What Are You Reading? #imway 11/30/15


Visit Teach Mentor Texts and Unleashing Readers to participate in this weekly meme.

On the blog:

In reading:

candy shop war

Is Brandon Mull’s The Candy Shop War really worse than any of the other mediocre-to-bad middle-grade series I’ve read aloud to my son? Probably not. But it is the latest, and I think it’s suffering the unfortunate fate of being my straw-that-breaks-the-camel’s-back book. I need a long break from mediocre middle-grade series! This book has a great deal of action, but somehow, I still found it so boring. I think my son did too: he fell asleep within a few pages every single night–which also meant that it took us WEEKS to finish it. There is no character development, no themes, and a lot of poorly constructed sentences to wade through. Mull’s books get rave reviews on Amazon and among the tween readers I know, but I’m hesitant to try Fablehaven or Five Kingdoms after reading this book.

koala hospital

Writer-photographer Suzi Eszterhas’s Koala Hospital is an absolute must-read for everyone. I mean, look at that cover! Who could resist that face?! I was resisting pretty well until I saw the book in person at NCTE and took a peek inside. So many more wonderful photos of ADORABLE koalas inside, plus so much interesting information. Eszterhas shares the work of doctors and volunteers at Australia’s Koala Hospital, which rescues and rehabilitates injured koalas and also strongly advocates for habitat preservation. Overall, an inspiring look at wildlife rescue and conservation.

ada bryon lovelace

Laurie Wallmark’s Ada Byron Lovelace and the Thinking Machine, beautifully illustrated by April Chu, introduces young readers to the life and work of Lovelace, who developed the world’s first computer program after meeting Charles Babbage, creator of the world’s first computer. Babbage’s machine was never made, so Lovelace’s program was purely conceptual–but when computer scientists ran the program, it did work (after the correction of a minor error). Lovelace came by her love of science and math honestly: her mother was famously learned and hired special tutors for her daughter. Wallmark focuses on Lovelace’s early interest in invention (she tried to create wings that would fly), her friendship with Babbage, and her theoretical work on computers. Transitions between page turns can be a bit rough, and I got lost a couple of times because I wasn’t sure when events were happening (there’s a strange lack of dates, ages, and chronological markers in this book), but it’s a strong introduction to an interesting and important thinker (and Chu’s illustrations are really pretty).

orbiting jupiter

I loved how spare Gary Schmidt’s new novel, Orbiting Jupiter, is. It’s a read-it-in-one-sitting kind of book. The style perfectly suits the subject matter and the setting–rural Maine in winter. I stopped to admire so many sentences and paragraphs. I won’t soon be forgetting the story. And yet….. even though I admired many elements of this book, it didn’t entirely work for me. I have spent a lot of time this week thinking about this book and my reaction to it. Later plot events seemed too coincidental and overwrought. I was frustrated by the ending–not because it packed an emotional wallop for me, as it seems to for many readers, but because it seemed so unlikely that it strained suspension of disbelief and took me right out of the novel. My ultimate feeling is that Schmidt sacrifices believable characters and story for thematic significance: theme most definitely trumps everything else in this story. That’s a very literary approach to take–and a daring one, especially in a middle-grade novel (though the ending, for me, moves this firmly into YA). It’s clear that this book is working for many readers, and I was sad not to love it.

frog and toad are friends

I revisited a very old friend this week, Frog and Toad Are Friends, after hearing Phillip Stead talk about it in his session with Erin Stead and Yasmeen Ismail at NCTE. This book was such a staple of my childhood, so often read and reread, that whole sentences came back to me as I was reading it this week. And there’s really nothing to say about it, except that it is so, so good. Lobel won a Caldecott Honor for the illustrations, but the book could easily have also won a Newbery for writing. Of course now I want to reread all of the Frog and Toad books, so I anticipate a library trip soon.





13 responses to “It’s Monday! What Are You Reading? #imway 11/30/15”

  1. Tara Smith Avatar

    Frog and Toad were hallmarks of my kids’ lives – we loved reading and re-reading that series. Thanks, too, for the honest reviews – I so appreciate these!

  2. jayciecheatham Avatar

    I am sad to say that I have only read one other book by Gary D. Schmit- The Wednesday Wars- but I loved it and after reading the book’s abstract on Amazon I am very intrigued by Orbiting Jupiter. The story sounds devastating, but potentially very beautiful. Only one way to find out for myself…

    1. Elisabeth Ellington Avatar

      Let me know if you’d like to borrow it! I need to reread The Wednesday Wars and Okay for Now. If you liked Wednesday Wars, I definitely think you’d like Okay for Now.

      1. jayciecheatham Avatar

        I’ll definitely have to check it out! I’m looking forward to having so much free reading time after I graduate this December! I still can’t believe it!

  3. Elizabeth Avatar

    I just read a Frog and Toad book to Owen. He was a little concerned about why they all laughed at Toad in his bathing suit! Poor Toad! He actually looked quite dapper.

  4. Scott Day Avatar

    I loved Orbiting Jupiter, but your comments are insightful. The book did seem overwrought. But since I primarily react to books emotionally, my emotional response to the book outweighed its being overwrought..

  5. Linda Baie Avatar

    Frog & Toad books are now favorites of my granddaughters, so great. We also like Owl At Home. Thanks for the reviews, sharing your own opinions about them, which I value, Elisabeth. I don’t read very many of those middle grade books, but you mentioned Fablehaven, a book that a former student (6th grader) thought was marvelous. Just saying’-I still haven’t read it. And I think some of the best middle grades are by Kate Messner.

  6. Jane Whittingham Avatar

    Oh, I still have my childhood copy of Owl at Home, I’ve kept it through countless moves because I loved Lobel so much. Timeless classics.

  7. Cheriee Weichel Avatar

    I have been waiting to read Orbiting Jupiter because I adored The Wednesday Wars and Okay For Now. It sounds like it will be an interesting read.
    Frog and Toad are still going strong. I have some Frog and Toad stuffies and love to see students sitting in the library reading the books and having the characters say their parts.

  8. Lisa Maucione (@DrLMaucione) Avatar

    Koala Hospital sounds great. Frog and Toad is such a classic. When I taught first grade the students loved them.

  9. Kellee from Unleashing Readers (@kelleemoye) Avatar

    I love Frog and Toad! I did one of my favorite lessons during grad school about them, and I created life size magnets of the two of them with a bunch of accessories. Such a blast!
    I need to read Orbiting Jupiter, but I am not sure if I want the crying it promises; however, I have only hear amazing things about it.

    Happy reading this week! 🙂

  10. Holly Mueller Avatar

    I’m excited to read Gary Schmidt’s new book. I have it from the library. Koala Hospital looks adorable!

  11. carriegelson Avatar

    I am in a Frog and Toad kind of mood too actually – one can never go wrong. In fact, I think I may read some aloud tomorrow.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: