It’s Monday! What Are You Reading? #imwayr 10/3/16

IMWAYR-2015-logoOn the blog:

In reading:


Kid Athletes is a collection of brief biographies of famous athletes. There are plenty of recognizable names (Michael Jordan, Muhammed Ali, Babe Ruth, Jackie Robinson), but also plenty of athletes that will be less familiar. There is an admirable effort at diversity both in terms of gender and ethnicity and in terms of sport. You’ll find race car drivers to sumo wrestlers represented. Doogie Horner’s humorous illustrations add liveliness to each page, and David Stabler’s writing ensures engagement by focusing on the childhoods of these “sports legends” and sharing tales (and maybe tall tales in some cases) that may be less familiar. Chapters are 10-15 pages or so–just the right length for breakfast time read-aloud, we discovered. A useful addition to any middle-grade collection.


Makoons is the fifth book in Louise Erdrich’s historical fiction saga that begins with The Birchbark House. This is such an important series and I wish it were better known and used in schools in place of some of the racist historical fiction that students continue to be exposed to. Makoons is especially strong in its depiction of dynamic multi-generational family relationships and its plentiful details about the daily life of the Ojibwe in the nineteenth century. There is perhaps more of a sad tone suffusing this book than others in the series. By the end of the novel, a way of life is also very close to its end. The scarcity of the buffalo becomes a plot thread and there is an especially poignant scene after a buffalo hunt when the buffalo themselves seem to have a vision of the future.


Judd Winick’s terrific graphic novels series continues with Hilo Saving the Whole Wide World. There were a bit too many Boom! Pow! Ptoom! action scenes for my taste, but for the target audience, it’s probably exactly right. Book 2 ends on a cliffhanger, so readers will anxiously await volume 3.


I loved Dan Santat’s illustrations in this silly fractured fairy tale, but I nearly lost my mind over the sing-song rhyme. The rhyme really gets in the way of anything surprising or clever that might happen in the writing.


Aaron Becker’s gorgeous trilogy concludes with Return. By now, readers are familiar with the plot, but the illustrations continue to dazzle.


Bill Thomson’s The Typewriter is a new favorite for me. A group of kids discover an old typewriter that magically creates whatever they type. There is such a love of wonder, mystery, and creativity at the heart of Thomson’s books, and the illustrations are magnificent. After my son and I finished reading this book, he demanded to know where Thomson’s Caldecott is. A fine question!


How I love Lauren Child’s books about Charlie and his little sister, Lola. In One Thing, they are about to accompany their mother to the store, where each has been promised they can buy “just one thing.” Child illustrates counting concepts and time concepts in this clever story.





13 responses to “It’s Monday! What Are You Reading? #imwayr 10/3/16”

  1. Scott Day Avatar

    Certainly agree with you and your son about a Caldecott for Thomson.Some pages of Return also left me breathless. A beautiful book. You might also like Are You an Echo? It’s a book about a Japanese poet, Misuzu Kaneko. Some of the poems are stunning.

    1. Elisabeth Ellington Avatar

      I really love it that my son knows Caldecott history enough to know Thomson doesn’t have one! I was a bit meh on the story in Return–mostly because I wanted it to work a little more independently of the other two books, and it really doesn’t–but yes, some of the illustrations are my favorites in the whole series.I will add Are You an Echo? to my list–thank you!

  2. carriegelson Avatar

    Hilo is VERY popular in my classroom – the perfect amount of BOOMs and POWs I would say for kid readers! Isn’t Return gorgeous? I think it might be my favourite cover of the three.

    1. Elisabeth Ellington Avatar

      Return is so beautiful. Some images there that I’d love to frame on my walls. I feel for your students having to wait til 2017 for Book 3 of Hilo!!

  3. readingtothecore Avatar

    I agree with you 100% about The Birchbark House and Erdrich’s other books in the series. I recommend it every chance I get. Kid Athletes and Hilo sound perfect for a few reluctant readers I’ve started working with this year. Thanks for sharing!

    1. Elisabeth Ellington Avatar

      I really do love Erdrich’s series. The books have been a tough sell for me with my college Children’s Lit students though, perhaps because they are slower moving books? I’m sure your reluctant readers would love Kid Athletes and Hilo. I might get Kid Presidents to share with my son too.

  4. lindabaie Avatar

    I have loved Erdrich’s stories, but still need to read Makoon. And I loved Return and The Typewriter, reminded me of Inkheart. I’ve known kids who thought the idea of things really appearing was wonderful. Thanks for “One Thing”, sounds like my daughter and granddaughters!

  5. nickybanz Avatar

    I just read Tracks by Erdrich’s and I absolutely loved it! She’s so unique in her writing style and plot lines. I can’t wait to get my hands on another one of her books.

  6. Michele Avatar

    The illustrations in Bill Thompson’s books really are quite amazing.
    I loved Return. I actually need to “return” to it for a reread, but my students have had it for awhile now!
    I enjoyed the first HiLo a bit more than this one, but like Carrie said, the kids absolutely adore this series.

  7. Jane the Raincity Librarian Avatar

    There are soooooo many Hilo fans at my library who are just gobbling this one up, and can’t wait for the next book already!! 🙂

  8. Beth Shaum (@BethShaum) Avatar

    I love that your son is so into picture books that he’s invested in who wins the Caldecott. 🙂

  9. Myra GB Avatar

    Glad to see a new Bill Thomson picturebook – I just reserved Return from our library, so really looking forward to it. I didn’t realize that Louise Erdrich’s novels are a quintet? Oh wow. I only have the first two, I believe (but haven’t gotten around to reading it yet).

  10. Elizabeth Avatar

    I love the Charlie and Lola books too! Owen tolerates them — he’ll “let” me read them to him, but he doesn’t get that excited about them (although I have noticed he quotes from them a lot). Right now we are both enjoying a book “Too Many Pears” (I think that’s the title), about a cow named Pamela who eats all the pears. It is very snicker worthy….

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: