And the winner is… Slice of Life #sol19

The 2019 ALA Youth Media Awards announcements happened to coincide with the home stretch of a long road trip, which at first confounded me. How could I possibly watch the Livestream, share reactions on Twitter, place holds on library books, order titles from Amazon, AND drive at the same time?? But I was confounded for only a moment. I had to sacrifice Twitter, but thanks to three cell phones, one laptop, a mother who agreed to stay home by her computer and place holds and order titles and a husband who agreed to text my book requests, my ALA YMA event was a success.

The ALA YMA Livestream is, I’m not ashamed to confess, one of my favorite events of the year. I try not to get too invested in the results, as it’s the reading and the discussions and the hopes and the surprises that are the most fun. But of course I often have favorites that I’m hoping will win.

I especially love years when committees push the envelope a bit by awarding unexpected books. The 2016 Newbery Committee was brilliant: awarding the gold medal to a picture book?! AND honoring a graphic novel?! The 2015 Committee was also pretty awesome: a SPORTS novel for the winner and a GRAPHIC NOVEL for an honor book.

Of course it’s also nice when a book I can’t stop talking about wins. 2017 was the best Caldecott year ever, as two books I was incredibly passionate about won the gold and an honor (Radiant Child and They All Saw a Cat.)

The Caldecott is probably my favorite award, both because picture books are my favorite book format and because I’ve almost always read the winner and all the honor books. This year, unusually, I didn’t have a favorite pick to win. I loved the surprise of The Rough Patch as an Honor Book (I’d read it just the week before, but it had been off my radar as a potential Caldecott title).

The students in my Children’s Literature course participated in a Mock Caldecott the week before the announcements. Most years, I’m able to include at least a couple of actual winners in our Mock Caldecott list, but this year, three of the five winners hadn’t even come in from the library, and The Rough Patch wasn’t on my Mock Caldecott list, so we only read A Big Mooncake for Little Star as part of our Mock Caldecott experience.

My students’ picks were solid (Blue was their winner, and they chose three honor books), but only one was honored with an actual award this year: Drawn Together won the Asian/Pacific American Award in the Picture Book category.

Even though none of their picks won a Caldecott, they still got to read around 20 terrific books and discover more about their own preferences as readers. And perhaps they will go on to host Mock Caldecotts in their own classrooms.

My favorite thing about the ALA YMA, of course, is all the reading. Reading before the awards and reading after. My mailbox and my library hold shelf are full of new books for several weeks after the awards. Right now, I’m in the middle of two Newbery books, Merci Suarez Changes Gears and The Night Diary. I’ve nearly caught up with the Geisel and Schneider Family Award books. And I’m looking forward to reading the Asian/Pacific American Award winners and honor books next. That’s a new-to-me award (though it’s been around since 2001–which means lots of great books to go back and discover!). I appreciate that the live announcements now include more of the diversity book awards, though I was disappointed that the honor books for the Asian/Pacific American Award weren’t listed during the ceremony.

I don’t think any of my Children’s Lit students has ever taken me up on the invitation to watch the Livestream event. Maybe one day I’ll get organized enough to schedule my course at a time when we can watch the event together.

Thanks to Clare at Teachers for Teachers for the title and inspiration for this slice.

15 responses to “And the winner is… Slice of Life #sol19”

    • I think it’s such a great way to flood students with brand new great books. There’s never a dud in the Mock Caldecott pile! I love starting the semester with this project since they get to read so many high quality picture books.

  1. I had to laugh at how you managed to drive, order, and reserve books. I hope your students do try to do a Mock Caldecott in their classes. I am so dismayed by the teachers who are not even aware of the winners after they are announced. In April, I have one last day with grade 3-5 teachers and I think I will do a Mock Caldecott with them. Perhaps they will be able to see the benefit of this. The sad part is all of the books I will bring will be new to them and they won’t know which one was the actual winner.

    • A couple of students have already said they’d like to try Mock Caldecotts in their classroom. Thankfully, there are some great resources to use. They’re passing the actual Caldecott winner around right now and really admiring it.

  2. A village is needed not just to raise a child but to also to help teachers with books. Like Elsie I am saddened by the number of teachers who are not aware of the winning books and therefore don’t make their students aware of them either. What a disservice.

    • It’s so convenient that the ALA YMAs are just at the beginning of the spring semester since they bring so many excellent books to our attention. I do end up spending more money than I probably should purchasing books, but new books are such a draw.

  3. The first part of your post made me laugh and adore you even more! I love that you do a Mock Caldecott – great ideas for new teachers.

  4. Ooh – I didn’t have any idea that they live streamed this event. And I love that you required a team and lots of tech to get through the event. Hee hee hee. As a high school teacher, I haven’t been super-aware of many of these awards, but the more I read picture books (and start to incorporate them into my classroom), the more I appreciate them. I wonder if I could do a mock awards pick with my students? hmm…

    • Yes! There are mock Printzes for YA lit, though I think the Printz is almost impossible to mock. Your students might especially enjoy a Mock Sibert with informational books. But I think they would enjoy picture books too. Such concise and crafted text. I think they work so beautifully to teach so many writing craft lessons. Several teacher-bloggers create terrific Mock Caldecott lists a few weeks before I do my unit, so I mostly borrow from them. My students seem to really enjoy it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: